Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> people migrate to alternative DNS schemes, such as GNS or Namecoin

"GNS" does not find anything relevant on first page of google results.

Namecoin would hardly be an improvement over current system, on the contrary a system where anyone can snatch any domain without any kind of mechanism for dispute seems like a step backwards. Especially when there is no top-level division of the namespace.



GNS is the GNU Name System: https://gnunet.org/gns

It is a kind of P2P petname system, but better.

I don't like Namecoin also, I was just saying that people should try alternatives, invent some, if Namecoin is not good for them. I like the GNS approach very much, but we should be thinking about implementation and/or alternatives.


GNU Name System seems interesting indeed. If I'm understanding it correctly you could mix'n'match centralized and decentralized stuff with it, eg you could delegate .com.gnu to VeriSign. But of course there is the little stumbling block that bootstrapping FoF/WoT style network is nearly impossible.

Actually I wonder if they could have used existing PGP key network as a basis for building their own system, eg do initial key exchange based on PGP keys.


Well, as I understand it, it is projected to work inside GNUnet, so, if they manage to get GNUnet, a highly challenging and multipurpose protocol (both to install yourself and much more to convince your friends to install) to be accepted by the public, the FoF network will be the easiest part.

I'm not into this existing PGP key network. What exactly do you mean by it? The key servers all around the world? Are there some apps/services that use this network for something? I always thought these servers were just sitting on piles of public keys and that nobody ever even looked at them.

This is pretty interesting. Where should I look at to get more information on this topic?


> much more to convince your friends to install

That is indeed the difficulty I referred to.

> I'm not into this existing PGP key network. What exactly do you mean by it? The key servers all around the world?

Keyservers are a small part of PGP WoT. The real magic is in the way keys are signed. I'm not going to try to explain how it works, there are many good writeups already on the net. You can start by reading the wikipedia article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_of_trust

The simplest way GNS could use PGP would be storing PGP public key => signed zkey mappings in the DHT, so that you could look up users zkey based on their PGP key. It is bit suboptimal because it still requires users to have separate keys, but I think it would be better than nothing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: