Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Too much perl code is essentially write once and forget.

Please stop repeating this misconception. People who put little effort into learning how to program write "write-once" code in any language. Perl had the "misfortune" of being the only dynamic language on the block for a long time, leading to many people reaching for it to get things done without bothering to actually learn the language, thus creating a vast corpus of low quality code.

(It does not help that the definitive resource of Perl for bioinformatics people, which i've seen in libraries like those of the Genome Campus in Cambridge, isn't worthy of being used as toilet paper, yet influenced a whole generation of scientists.)

> I've spent far too many hours trying to figure out what a perl script does

How often do you reach for perltidy when you do this?



I don't think that is a misconception.

Perl is the language with the highest occurrence of "subtle" and "ambiguous" in its documentation and tutorials that I have ever seen. Humans may be subtle and ambiguous, but programming languages should be clear and precise.


If you contrast the original statement i quoted as a misconception, you will find that your opinion still is not the same as the actual misconception.


What is this "definitive resource" and what resource would you recommend for learning perl? I'm learning now (self-teaching) and don't want to learn the wrong way.

Here's the book I've been using: http://bixsolutions.net/


The two books I'd strongly recommend:

* chromatic's "Modern Perl" - which has a free CC licenced version (although it would be nice for you to pay some money to support the good work of the author and publisher ;-) http://www.onyxneon.com/books/modern_perl/index.html

* Curtis Poe's "Beginning Perl" http://ofps.oreilly.com/titles/9781118013847/

(Bias warning: Curtis is a mate - but it is a very good book on the topic. Honest ;-)


Thanks for these - much appreciated!


I do not remember the exact title anymore. It was a book that taught how to build web applications by interleaving data retrieval and html printing, instead of building it up in proper MVC fashion, to name one example of the damage it did.

As for learning Perl, the best resource is http://perl-tutorial.org

You will find an explanation there of how to judge a learning resource and a list of the most current texts that teach modern Perl.


Thanks man, much appreciated :)


"Proper" MVC fashion.


Please elaborate. :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: