Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Protest every weekend? build momentum until this can't be ignored? perhaps write to congressmen? attend townhall meetings and ask questions to your representatives? try to raise awareness to your friends who don't vote?

I have an American friend who keeps complaining about Trump. There was a protest in his city, but he didn't go because he had a BBQ to attend that weekend.

Seriously, this isn't fun anymore and Americans should be extremely concerned and start acting one way or another. It may be symbolic but it's better than nothing, if only for peace of mind.



Representatives already either agree it's bad (and can't do much about it) or will not listen to the public (because they're Republicans and indented to trump for their careers.

I don't have any friends who don't vote, really, and the midterms might not come soon enough to do anything here.

My senator had a head injury and reversed all his opinions for some reason, so I've called his office a lot but he's very pro Invading Greenland now, and pro criminalizing his voters. Unhelpful guy.

I would start preparing for all of this to happen, and tell your friend to get his passport up to date.


RIP the man Fetterman used to be.


> Representatives already either agree it's bad (and can't do much about it)

Representatives can draft articles of impeached for the President.

Senators can start impeaching various Secretaries like Defence ("War") and Homeland Security. Or all of the Secretaries really, since they're not upholding the Constitution themselves by not invoking the 25A to get rid of a mentally unstable President.

Where are all these much-vaunted "checks and balances" that I've been hearing about for so long?


> Where are all these much-vaunted "checks and balances" that I've been hearing about for so long?

That's the problem, turns out there are none.

Or to be more precise, they do exist but they rely solely on each arm of the government acting in good faith and respecting the boundaries of their power and deferring on powers that belong to a different arm of the government.

But turns out there was a 0-day bug in the constitution: if the president simply completely ignores all other branches of government, nothing can be done about it.


Did you pay attention to his last impeachment?

The much vaunted checks and balances rely on Congress and the supreme Court checking the executives power. Since the presidents party controls both, this doesn't happen. The Imperial Presidency has been absorbing power from the other branches since the 90s, and we are pretty close to the end of that process right now.


> The Imperial Presidency has been absorbing power from the other branches since the 90s

70s, at the latest. 30s, realistically and bipartisanly speaking.


I read "Imperial Presidency" and instantly thought "Vote Palpatine/Vader 2024. What's the worst that could happen?"

:(


> Representatives can draft articles of impeached for the President.

Trump has been impeached twice. Even if you could get enough Republicans in the House on board to do so a third time (the GOP holds a majority in both houses of Congress), the threshold of 2/3 of the Senate to convict and remove is far out of reach; there aren't enough Republicans that aren't die-hard Trump loyalists (there are rumors that an actual armed invasion of Greenland might change that, but those kind of rumors of opposition often turn out to be overblown when situations materialize, with a decisive number Republicans offering some criticism and then finding an excuse to oppose actual action.)

> Senators can start impeaching various Secretaries

No, Senators cannot start impeachment, which regardless of which officers subject to it are targeted must start in the House. And the same problems which face impeachment of the President apply here.

> Where are all these much-vaunted "checks and balances" that I've been hearing about for so long?

They rely on the same malign faction not controlling both political branches as well as dominating the Supreme Court at the same time. Unfortunately...


When the Republican Party has been largely purged of opposition to Trump (except for senators Rand Paul, Susan Collins, and Lisa Murkowski and a tiny handful of people in the House), and when six out of nine Supreme Court justices are generally loyal to the GOP, then there are effectively no checks and balances.

Trump learned during his first term that he can bypass checks and balances by making sure the GOP is thoroughly MAGA. People who stood up to Trump have been sidelined, such as Justin Amash, Mitt Romney, and, most famously, Mike Pence, who stood up to Trump on January 6 and paid a heavy political price for it. That’s why Vance, not Pence, is the current VP.


> Protest every weekend?

Have protests ever stopped the creation of a dictatorship, in history?

> build momentum until this can't be ignored?

Your answer to "how do we stop this" is "do something until it stops."

> perhaps write to congressmen?

"Dear official who actively supports subverting our democracy: Please don't."

> attend townhall meetings and ask questions to your representatives?

Filed under "Rearrange the desk chairs."

> try to raise awareness to your friends who don't vote?

This (alone) would have the ability to change things... but at this point, they are hiding that shameful fact. Non-voters and supporters of third parties in the US are effectively supporting the status quo.

You didn't suggest this, but I already employee a spicy bumpersticker that complains about Trump, and give stern looks to the screen when the news reports on abuses of law.


> Your answer to "how do we stop this" is "do something until it stops."

That is, in part, a major aspect of resistance, yes. Protests on the weekends are great for community engagement and visibility, but constant pressure and activism are necessary. I think Minneapolis is a great example of how people should react when the situation gets bad. But even before that, getting involved in local organizations so that you're ready to help your neighbors is huge. For those of us not in Minneapolis, a general strikes would be great.


> Have protests ever stopped the creation of a dictatorship, in history?

They have in my country: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_2009_Moldovan_parliament...

And in Ukraine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euromaidan

And in many other places.


> Have protests ever stopped the creation of a dictatorship, in history?

They do have the ability to change the course of actions. But even if it's just symbolic, massive protests would show the world that Americans aren't all in favor of the regime in place and some have a functioning morale compass.


> Have protests ever stopped the creation of a dictatorship, in history?

It sends a message to the less active people who might turn off news that somethings is ain't right. Next time they might even vote.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: