Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The example you linked is about push notifications in general, nothing specific to the Signal app. If the concern is that your OS is compromised or spying on you, that's not something E2E encryption can protect against, whether it's Signal or any other app.


> nothing specific to the Signal app

The specific part is that Signal forces Google and Apple on its users, and forces the specific kind of push notifications, too.


Signal works fine on degoogled LineageOS, so I'm not sure that's true.


LineageOS is Google's Android. Try to run Signal on a Pinephone.


You can use linux clients just fine, like gurk, which I linked you in another comment.


AFAIK I must connect it to Android or iOS before I can use it.


I don't think so, you could use the official Linux build as far as I know. I think it needs a phone number but not necessarily a mobile device. I might be wrong though.


It required to scan the QR code from a "mobile" app last time I tried.

(You really have a lot of free time to write unsubstantiated dismissals to all my posts.)


> It required to scan the QR code from a "mobile" app last time I tried.

Are you against using an Android (or LineageOS) emulator to do so?

> (You really have a lot of free time to write unsubstantiated dismissals to all my posts.)

You pop up in a lot of threads I'm interested in and seem to say a lot of incorrect things, that's all.


> Are you against using an Android (or LineageOS) emulator to do so?

1. It's annoying and inconvenient.

2. It's the result of an artificial restriction by Moxie, for which I can't see any good reason, making me suspicious. In my opinion, this is basically an attack on true mobile freedom.

3. I do not believe in a good app isolation of Waydroid, so I would prefer to use as rare as possible. I also do not trust Android too much. And I will have to run two Signal apps simultaneously.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: