Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Helicopter. Already exists.


Helicopters have a significant safety problem.

https://stopthechopnynj.org/safety-and-terrorism/?utm_source...


More people are killed in motor vehicle accidents in a single month in NY than in all of the incidents listed on that page spanning 58 years.


I like the terrorism section here, which lists zero terrorist attacks (because there haven’t been any) and loads of supposed risks…

And yet!


Drone like flying vehicles are much safer and cheaper than helicopters. Or will be at least.


I don't really agree with that. Helicopters can auto-rotate, drones can't. If something goes wrong with a drone system, it is going to crash hard guaranteed and likely doesn't have any meaningful control on the way down.


How will they be?

Literally any failure of the aircraft means you die.


No they have multiple engines and can survive failures.


Well yeah, it would be like a cheap helicopter you can rent. What is so bad about that.


"Cheap" and "Helicopter"

That's where the problem is.


It's certainly not crazy to imagine that you could cut the costs of a helicopter-like aircraft that was purpose-made for relatively short, relatively low-speed, relatively light load duties.


The energy cost during operations is very relevant, too, which is why you see things like tilt rotor designs with wings/bodies to generate lift.

When Airbus was doing the math on these a few years ago, the pilot cost was also one of the main concerns, so it was "autonomous or bust", and they ended up investing a lot on the autonomous side (not just the aircraft but also urban traffic management, etc).





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: