Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> What things are "non-political"?

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/politics

Narrow sense:

> the art or science of government: as [that] concerned with guiding or influencing governmental policy, ... [or] winning and holding control over a government; political actions, practices, policies, ... affairs or business

Broad sense:

> the total complex of relations between people living in society

In my experience, the question is almost always disingenuous. Topics being "political" is clearly the exception rather than the norm. The subtext of asking is something like "you are a bad person for objecting to my political statements (but I will still reserve the right to object to yours, should you decide that turnabout is fair play)".

> Saying "there are no politics" seems like the same thing as "the status quo is the only possibility" - exactly the stagnation from which I want to move away on socials.

There are all kinds of projects and activities that can be discussed without touching upon the relations between people in society, let alone matters of governmental policy or the quest for power.

There is nothing at all "stagnant" about a community focused on such things. OP is about the Free Software Foundation; focusing on discussion of the software has nothing to do with politics, and is generally improved by consciously avoiding politics.

The mere fact of existence of other political possibilities does not necessitate discussing those possibilities at every opportunity.



Actually OP is about the Free Software Foundation Europe, an organization that empowers users to control technology.

A number of their campaigns have direct policy/political goals: Public Money Public Code, Device Neutrality, etc.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: