Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If the US can build safer cars for everyone, the EU will have no objections.


[flagged]


EU legislation requires a number of design considerations for pedestrian and cyclist collisions, like specific energy absorption requirements for front-impact and side-impact protection, restrictions on sharp corners/steep angles that could concentrate impact forces, minimum clearance around hard internal structures, mandatory ADAS (automated emergency braking, lane departure warnings) etc. Not saying that US cars are "not safe" in a binary fashion but for the most part these things are either optional or unregulated in the US.


Yeah, not a fan of cyclists. And it's kind of braindead to have my car break because if I hit a pedestrian somehow it is its job to absorb the impact. Maybe cyclists and pedestrians should be more mindful of their surroundings.

The EU regulations have killed all the nice things about cars: straight lines, retractable headlights and so on.


The two ton deadly weapon is definitely the one at fault, not the person just living life.

There is no nice things about cars.


You know what else will be braindead in your nice world? The child who runs out in front of a car after a rigid tight-angled metal corner drives into their skull. These regulations aren't about blame or "drivers/pedestrians/cyclists should be more aware!", they're about reducing or avoiding as much harm as possible when things don't go to plan and an accident happens.


I guess you can ask the parents why the kid was unsupervised, no? Not blame the car.


You seem to be desperate to talk about blame but ultimately they're called accidents for a reason. Not because we want them to happen, not because we can always prevent them. Regulations like this are about changing the outcome, not the initial reason it happened.


I am saying it is a BS regulation to have a car that breaks itself if it hits someone.


Did you even read the article?


Yes. It started with the BS of "US would undermine the EU’s global leadership in road safety, public health, climate policy and competitiveness.". The only thing the EU has a global leadership is killing everything with regulations and bureaucracy.


Can you share your sources or data where it says US is safer in terms of road safety.?


Here, I googled it for you: "The European Union generally has higher road safety standards than the US, resulting in significantly lower fatality rates. The EU mandates stricter vehicle safety features, including automated emergency braking, and has more stringent traffic laws regarding speed, seat belts, and drunk driving. In contrast, the US has higher average vehicle weights and a less consistent application of safety regulations." and it proves my point: the EU just regulates stuff to death.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: