Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I never implied that, let alone said it.

The only thing I implied is that workers with fewer rights that a U.S. citizen are easier to exploit and abuse.

If I refuse to take a work-related call at 3am, the worst that can happen is that I get fired, and spend months looking for a new job.

If you refuse to take a work-related call at 3am, you get fired and lose your ability to stay in a place you have lived for 5+ years and made your home.

That's BS, and I hate it almost as much as you do. You can be blackmailed with deportation, and I can be replaced with someone who can be blackmailed with deportation. We're both getting screwed in this current arrangement.



Requesting work-related calls at 3am should be illegal and is in a lot of places.


I doubt it's illegal in many places.

What is common is that being available counts as work.


Your work hours are specified in your work contract. Demanding service without compensation and contract sounds highly illegal.


We have on-call duty for this. It should perhaps be compensated differently, and certainly one person should not always be on-call (though I have been at times on-call for months at a time, but for a thing that normally does not page at night). But what are we do to, have staff around the world so that someone can be on-call during their local business hours so we can have 24/7 support?


Nice exchange. Both points are valid.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: