Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They should always have had a second, back-up option, because relying on such a brittle a thing as satellite comms when fighting a military power like Russia was bound to have issues.


I'm pretty sure they know that. Especially as Starlink is brittle mostly because of its (rather disgusting at this point) founder figure and his ramblings. But this is armchair advice: what other options do they have and how do you fund them?

(most of Starlink for the Ukrainian army is being paid for by Poland)


Eutelsat OneWeb, I believe I read that it's already been deployed Ukraine. I might be wrong but I think I heard it on "Ukraine, the latest" podcast.


Go look up how much it costs


You think Ukraine is paying full price?


Yes I do.


>most of Starlink for the Ukrainian army is being paid for by Poland

This isn't true either by $amount or number of dishes

SATCOM is brittle because physics.

Especially outside C band.


> This isn't true either by $amount or number of dishes

"Poland is the largest single contributor, paying approximately $50 million per year through its Digital Affairs Ministry for Starlink services in Ukraine. Poland has provided over 20,000 Starlink terminals and covers the ongoing subscription costs. As of recent reports, Poland has spent nearly 323 million PLN ($84 million) on more than 24,500 Starlink terminals over the past two years." (reuters)

Or, if you'd like somewhat outdated info from Wikipedia: "As of December 2023, Poland remains the largest single contributor of Starlink terminals to Ukraine, providing 19,500 out of 47,000 delivered"


There are over 100k dishes in Ukraine. Most are privately purchased.

That number represents the government(s) supplied numbers.

Take a look at this contract.

https://www.usaspending.gov/award/CONT_AWD_HC101324F0143_970...

Also Poland is definitely paying public retail prices.

The US on the other hand isn't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: