It's a bit like the choice between two doctors. One is very polite, spends an hour by your bedside every day, smiles and holds your hand and encourages you not to give up but has no idea about how to interpret your symptoms, has a horribly confused idea of what's going on but can explain that mess in his head to you in a reassuring tone that feels authoritative.
The other doc is morose, doesn't smile, the meetings are brief like an interrogation but he knows exactly what's up, spends the time on reading the literature, case studies, phones up other doctors who treated similar illnesses, cuts you and sews you back at the right spot and hands you the exact pills that will get you on your feet in a few months, but at the same time was distant and cold throughout the whole thing and talked to you as if you were a car in the repairshop.
Ideally, it would be both. Of the two I'd still choose the second guy.
It's a bit like the choice between two doctors. One is very polite, spends an hour by your bedside every day, smiles and holds your hand and encourages you not to give up but has no idea about how to interpret your symptoms, has a horribly confused idea of what's going on but can explain that mess in his head to you in a reassuring tone that feels authoritative.
The other doc is morose, doesn't smile, the meetings are brief like an interrogation but he knows exactly what's up, spends the time on reading the literature, case studies, phones up other doctors who treated similar illnesses, cuts you and sews you back at the right spot and hands you the exact pills that will get you on your feet in a few months, but at the same time was distant and cold throughout the whole thing and talked to you as if you were a car in the repairshop.
Ideally, it would be both. Of the two I'd still choose the second guy.