Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Let's not forget that some of real pirates (for example, corsairs) also were legal and performed legitimate pirate activities to ships of foreign countries.

In other words there are activities that are legal or not depending on whether you have authorization from the state. That describes many things. For instance you synthesize meth without a license from the DEA/FDA, you're a "drug cartel" or whatever. But if you do it with a license you're a "pharmaceutical company", and you're not making "meth", you're making "desoxyn".



Synthesizing chemical substances doesn't involve murdering people though.


Families of fentanyl overdose victims would disagree. Moreover it's not hard to find examples of "legal if the government authorizes it" for killings. Cops and soldiers, for instance.


It takes quite a leap of logic to blame someone ingesting a toxic quantity of a substance on the person who manufactured the substance. When someone drinks bleach do we blame the company that makes the bleach?


It is a bad comparison because substance vendor doesn't kill anyone just as a gun store doesn't. Soldiers are better analogy though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: