Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think it's mostly a very good idea, but much less accessible compared to the omnipresent bookmarks bar, so I will keep using the bookmarks bar (whose primary downside is the vendor lock in, imo).


Genuine question: why using the bookmark bar which is so tiny (a narrow 30 pixel high bar) to browse through thousands of bookmarks, when you can comfortably move/delete/rename/group in folders/use CTRL-C, CTRL-V, CTRL-X, CTRL-Z to undo/etc. in a big file explorer window?

My point is: the file explorer seems to have (at least for me) a far better UX than the browser's bookmark bar.

Example: you accidentally renamed a bookmark in the bookmark bar. Can you do CTRL-Z? No! With files in file explorer, you could.


I guess i don’t do those modifications very much.

Also im a avid user of keyword bookmarks in Firefox, so I need to store those in Firefox anyway for them to work


> whose primary downside is the vendor lock in, imo

I fail to see how bookmarks have vendor lock in. Every browser I've used has bookmark import/export to a format understandable by other browsers, like HTML.


I just meant that you can’t keep them in sync between browsers. You need a external program for that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: