Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Still, there should be a mechanism to avoid bringing up the same issue every year or two. Maybe 5 or 10 years.


This mechanism would be prone to abuse: a group that opposes a particular issue could effectively time that issue out to prevent a replacement group from pursuing it.

The adage about “being the worst system except for all the other ones” applies well here: your (and my) participation in democracy is a required component, not just a nice thing to have. Devising hacks around our participation will ultimately result in a system that doesn’t allow our participation.


The mechanism is for people to vote for representatives who don't bring up those issues every year or two. The problem is that people just vote along party lines, and then vote for incumbents within those party lines. Without the threat of losing their office, politicians have no incentive to change their behavior from year to year.

Think about how your suggestion would work for other topics, like crime, immigration, social services, etc. It would undermine the government's ability to respond quickly to changes in the external world. It's not worth doing that over this one issue, when the real solution is to just vote for better candidates.


That'd slow down decision making a lot. Imagine the effects this would have at the current pace climate changes are affecting the weather


It will only be brought up again if there's a chance that the representatives you vote for will back it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: