Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Similarily, you could use the example of two people, Alice and Bob. Alice has free will, but Bob doesn't. How would their behavior differ?

I've never seen an answer to this question, which hints that the question itself is ill-formed.



I think Free Will basically means that nobody else can force us to will, to desire, to like what we like.

A non-free-will would be something where somebody else controls my mind. Like you could imagine hearing thoughts in your head which you think are thought by someone else, like in schizophrenia I guess.

You can force me to do something but you cannot force me to will/want/like anything.


Bob would become non-deterministic. It’s a bit like when we add async to an old JS project. Once you await, you can’t stop!

Now, you’re looking sideways. Try looking down at a bunch of little Bobs. That’s where it gets interesting in my opinion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: