Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's the left-to-right ordering that's the problem. I'm fairly sure there's no way to order things left-to-right in this layout without inevitably having to skip around haphazardly.

In a magazine-style layout, wouldn't you read the columns top-to-bottom first, then left-to-right? You can accomplish that already in CSS with either 'columns' or vertical flexbox.

Another issue with this 'masonry' layout is the ragged edge at the bottom. In a magazine that would presumably be justified -- again something you can do with columns or flex.

On the web, I guess there's a hidden assumption that you'll have endless scrolling content, so it doesn't matter what the bottom of the page looks like? If so, that's not necessarily something that should be encouraged.



The main use for this will presumably be infinite scroll where columns doesn't work because it'd break all expectations when scrolling.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: