Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They remove pwas in latest ios beta(only in the EU) they are evil


I'm as disappointed in the new rules as anyone, but I'm going to call this one as most likely just a missing implementation rather than malicious.

The new Browser Engine Kit that allows alternative browsers to be installed is really a very deep integration. It's not just swapping out the browser and engine that users open as an app, it's swapping out all system integrations – webviews embedded in apps (in certain types of use), and importantly, PWAs pinned to the home screen. The APIs have a fairly sizeable surface area, and PWAs themselves have many features that require system support to implement.

My assumption would be that full PWA support will return, but that it was a significant amount of extra work that Apple decided to skip for the first implementation. I'm not sure if that was the right call, but they were under quite a deadline with the DMA coming in.


Yeah it was too much work to support PWAs in the EU for this beta. But they managed to have time to implement it for the rest of the world


I think that’s a little disingenuous, it already works for the rest of the world so of course they had time to implement it, grabbing where you live via an internal API and disabling functionality is easier to do than implementing a browser selection prompt and exposing possibly new APIs to new browsers.


That’s my point


Wait, is this confirmed that it's removed only in the EU? I've seen "reports" on Twitter (never gonna call it X) but nothing official.


It certainly seems that way:

https://appleinsider.com/articles/24/02/09/something-is-happ...

Without clear communication from Apple, people will assume that the change is a strategic move by Apple to not cede ground being lost due to the Digital Markets Act.


Officially they haven't confirmed anything(employees deny to comment) but it seems intentional in all aspects and bug report is silent


I hadn't heard about this, but it is indeed concerning. After my latest round of trying to publish apps on the iOS App Store, I concluded that PWAs were the best bet to getting a nice, polished user-experience without the soul-crushing process that is app store publishing.

I suppose a small bit of light (for me, not the community at-large) is that all of my targeted market is in the US. But I also acknowledge is they get away with that in the EU, the US will be next. Le sigh. This is why the Web is the best platform.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: