Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Working outside and getting scratched a lot in modern clean clothes, sterile tools, and with refrigerated food is still very very different to not having those things.


Let's circle back and remember that my post was a study of birth, death, and medical records, to which the response was "that doesn't feel right."

The data suggests your feelings are incorrect, and that things were not as dangerous as you feel they are. I'm not even sure what you mean in this case at all: people still washed their clothes, garden tools are not any more sterile now than they were then, and refrigeration can be worked around by different dietary and food storage choices. (Ironically the need for refrigeration partially came with societal advancement: fresh milk for example was traveling farther and farther and increasingly transactional circumstances, which meant it was more likely to carry food-borne diseases whereas, when you go further back, nobody was waiting days to drink their fresh milk and thus didn't worry about it.)

I’ve no doubt that there was a statistical impact, but it is probably rendered invisible by such things as skyrocketing obesity, heart disease, and cancer rates caused by the modern environment and lifestyle. This is probably especially true when you consider the QoL of many older people today. This is also apparent when the cited article mentions that many fewer people died of heart disease, but they did die of heart damage caused by infections. They lived just as long, you might think antibiotics would keep us going even longer, but we tread water because now we simply die of heart disease at about the same age or a little younger instead.


Certainly, my post is not meant to be a refutation of the study. I can express why it feels wrong, still.

Most of the feels is from personal experience with almost losing kids and spouse to infections. In the modern world. :) They 90% would be dead in the past.

Similar experience with grand parents. Though, they did pass somewhat early.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: