Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Spotify (on Android) is the worst offender for this.

The playlist shortcut shows six playlists, but 2-5 seconds after rendering these, about the same time it takes you scan over them and see if the playlist you want is offered in this set and get your finger into position, it re-renders them with different content & different order.

The full playlist selection does the same thing, using some hybrid and opaque MFU / MRU algorithm -- I'd be delighted with a pure alphabetical ordering, rather than having to visually scan down an unsorted list that's re-ordering itself as I read.

Mind, the Spotify UI can be held up as a shining example for basically every user-hostile anti-pattern, so I guess there's some consistency in their design.



For me it's Twitter for Android. It keeps loading new tweets to replace tweets I'm actively reading in the timeline.


Interesting, I've encountered a lot of problems with Spotify on Android, but not that one.

I did have to do some work to track down the alphabetical ordering feature for my playlist listing, after they unset it and moved it, but it is possible to set it, at least for the main listing (I find the MRU thing helpful for the "Add to playlist" menu, so I don't mind that I don't know if it's possible to set it there).


Yep, Spotify immediately came to mind after reading the title. Happens on iOS too.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: