Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The "Move" to POS breaks the myth of the system being immutable and "governance-free". The people with a lot of stake in the system can change or prevent change to the system. One of the major reasons that POS takes so long to implement is that individuals and syndicates that have invested a lot of money in to POW infrastructure block it and warn that it "doing it hastily" will harm the stability of the system. And they are right, it will harm the stability of the system because it is centralized and is governed by the individuals and syndicates with the most vested interest.


>>The people with a lot of stake in the system can change or prevent change to the system.

This is very misinformed. There is no governance by stake vote in Ethereum. The protocol is immutable absent a user willingly updating their node software to run a different protocol.

Stake is used exactly the same way hash generation hardware is used in PoW: to determine what share of blocks a person produces. This is safe in both Ethereum PoS and PoW as long as the assumption that 51% of block generation capital (stake, and hashing hardware, respectively) is controlled by honest parties holds true.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: