>So using that tool suddenly brings that antagonism and power into a team which is supposed to be 100% collaborative, and it also only does it periodically and with random and different people in power.
Is code review not collaborative in your experience? In every team I've been on/run we've split code review comments between suggestions/questions and actual "I will not let this go into prod if my name is attached to it" blockers. Code review has been 99% the first set of comments and only rarely do I see anyone actually block reviews over things like style and what not that have been mentioned here.
I can't even imagine those topics getting into code review as a blocker as if we have actually strongly held opinions on mechanical issues like that, they are integrated into the various linters used so you don't even need human eyes to catch the issue.
Is code review not collaborative in your experience? In every team I've been on/run we've split code review comments between suggestions/questions and actual "I will not let this go into prod if my name is attached to it" blockers. Code review has been 99% the first set of comments and only rarely do I see anyone actually block reviews over things like style and what not that have been mentioned here.
I can't even imagine those topics getting into code review as a blocker as if we have actually strongly held opinions on mechanical issues like that, they are integrated into the various linters used so you don't even need human eyes to catch the issue.