Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Those places are sadly lacking even in the most basic standards of education, so their potential ACT scores are frankly irrelevant as is admission to MIT. You gotta learn to crawl before you can walk, and walk before you can run.


Not only is this analogy wrong (there are plenty of animals that run the moment they are born) but it is also deeply insensitive.

The reason people do worse from underprivileged is not only the lack of quality education, but a fundamental difference in the quality of life. Everything from the diet, to available time, and noise pollution, all makes a difference on education level. Our education system relies heavily on outside help, and poorer neighborhoods often don’t have the time and energy to give their kids even the most basic help with their homework.


> Everything from the diet, to available time, and noise pollution, all makes a difference on education level. Our education system relies heavily on outside help, and poorer neighborhoods often don’t have the time and energy to give their kids even the most basic help with their homework.

Well said. Thanks for elaborating on my point.


The analogy is correct because we’re talking about people.

Parents are the primary educators. When they aren’t educating, or need to educate on too many other things, academics suffer. This is news to nobody. It would be highly suspicious if environment had no influence on educational outcomes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: