Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Reading did that for me.

> They were one of the few avenues I had for connecting with my peers

Three hours a week isn't much, but it doesn't have to be gaming to connect with people of your age, isn't it?

> It wasn't some waste of time that I regret when I look back as an adult.

I don't think it's what worries the Chinese government. Or me.

I'm quite sure that e.g. a 1 hr/day limit would be a good thing. You can say "parents", but at one point children stop listening. Then what do you do?



> Reading did that for me.

Reading decidedly did not do that for me. I didn't have the attention span for/interest in most books.

> but it doesn't have to be gaming to connect with people of your age, isn't it?

Socializing was always difficult for me. Gaming was one of the few things I could mention and my peers would say "oh, me too!"

> I'm quite sure that e.g. a 1 hr/day limit would be a good thing

That would be more than twice the limit described

> You can say "parents", but at one point children stop listening. Then what do you do?

My parents actually did limit me to 30m/day on weekdays (they took the limits off on weekends). I don't know why you suggest that I could've simply ignored them (but somehow couldn't ignore a government mandate?).

When I would reach my limit for the day I'd generally do what homework I had (fair enough), and then... do nothing. Mindlessly watch TV out of total boredom. Looking back, I'm not sure why they thought that was better.

Anyway: the common theme for this and all other totalitarian ideas is that individuals are different people with different needs, and what's best for one isn't best for others.


I assume a government mandate would be controlled at the ISP level. Most parents aren't tech savy enough for that. As a child, I was easily able to hide playing games.


Reading books is not all that different from gaming from the point of view of value to a child's development. It's escapism, it's a much more solo activity than many online games today, and the primary skills it encourages - reading and imagination - is available in most games to one degree or another.

To put another way, they could limit reading to 3 hours a week for mostly the same reasons.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: