But it's just a totally different situation isn't it? I'm not personally opposed to the general concept of security cameras in public spaces. If you choose to install one on your property that doesn't seem unreasonable. If you choose to share that footage with the police that doesn't seem unreasonable.
The problem with Apple's system isn't even the current implementation (which is on device, but iCloud only). It's that the system can be trivially expanded to all on device content, and report the user of the phone for any unacceptable behaviour.
It's more like a camera in your home that reports you to the police if you do anything unacceptable. Would anyone choose to have that?
But the bigger problem is that Apple have been selling products based on "privacy first" marketing. By reporting on their users off-line content they break that trust. And there are really few viable options in smartphones so you can't really just move to another provider.
But it's just a totally different situation isn't it? I'm not personally opposed to the general concept of security cameras in public spaces. If you choose to install one on your property that doesn't seem unreasonable. If you choose to share that footage with the police that doesn't seem unreasonable.
The problem with Apple's system isn't even the current implementation (which is on device, but iCloud only). It's that the system can be trivially expanded to all on device content, and report the user of the phone for any unacceptable behaviour.
It's more like a camera in your home that reports you to the police if you do anything unacceptable. Would anyone choose to have that?
But the bigger problem is that Apple have been selling products based on "privacy first" marketing. By reporting on their users off-line content they break that trust. And there are really few viable options in smartphones so you can't really just move to another provider.