Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

27.5MB, of which 27MB is five GIFs. Please don’t use GIFs like this. Use videos: they use less bandwidth, use less power, look better, and annoy your “I don’t want videos to autoplay!” users less.


Autoplaying (without the possibility of sound) is a feature, It's a huge aesthetic boon to the web. GIF is an entirely different conceptual flavor to video. It's good precisely because people almost never fuck with the fact that it autoplays.


When I say I don’t want things to autoplay, I mean it. Please don’t try to second-guess me. I don’t want anything autoplaying.

That GIFs autoplay is unequivocally a bug. Just a well-entrenched one that would take a lot of effort to fix, and no one capable of fixing it seems to quite think it’s worth it.

There are multiple reasons I might not want autoplay: bandwidth or performance concerns, accessibility problems from motion, or even just the simple “if you autoplay, then when I reach it it won’t be at the start of the video any more”.


agreed. I just cant focus on the text when there is giant motion right next to it


This seems something that could be fixed in the browser as a preference.


Unfortunately it’s not that easy. Images (animated or not) go through a very different pipeline to videos, and it would be a lot of work to make animated images behave like videos.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: