"a bunch of protocol stuff that would be problematic once being payed for."
And there lies the rub. It is not that NN means ISPs aren't allowed to manage their networks and have to let it all melt down into a cesspool of fully congested non yielding packet spewers (which is a strawman the industry likes to portray).
If network traffic is shaped transparently and non-discriminatory (for competing services types, e.g. buffering all latency robust VoD traffic while letting all eSports gaming packets skip the queue to increase overall Quality of Experience (quality as experienced by the end users rather than pure IP level QoS is not a problem) to provide a fair playing field for service providers (favoring a YouTube packet over a Vimeo packet because the former cut you a deal is not OK) and customers (dropping Anna's Instagram packets because she did not order the 'social' option for a few dollars more, or more likely, Zero rating Instagram packets against a volume cap whereas TikTok traffic is not excused) , there is no NN problem
Intents in regulation are a thing. Disputes on interpretations and compliance are a normal part of the process.
And there lies the rub. It is not that NN means ISPs aren't allowed to manage their networks and have to let it all melt down into a cesspool of fully congested non yielding packet spewers (which is a strawman the industry likes to portray).
If network traffic is shaped transparently and non-discriminatory (for competing services types, e.g. buffering all latency robust VoD traffic while letting all eSports gaming packets skip the queue to increase overall Quality of Experience (quality as experienced by the end users rather than pure IP level QoS is not a problem) to provide a fair playing field for service providers (favoring a YouTube packet over a Vimeo packet because the former cut you a deal is not OK) and customers (dropping Anna's Instagram packets because she did not order the 'social' option for a few dollars more, or more likely, Zero rating Instagram packets against a volume cap whereas TikTok traffic is not excused) , there is no NN problem
Intents in regulation are a thing. Disputes on interpretations and compliance are a normal part of the process.