> Any userspace process can see how low the memory is though
How, exactly?
Or put another way, how do you reliably tell apart "we are seriously thrashing" and "resident memory is getting close to the physical memory limits but there is plenty of totally cold stuff to swap out and it won't be a problem" from userspace? The kernel is the only thing that can make that determination somewhat reliably.
Maybe there's a better way than this, but the same way earlyoom decides it's time to kill processes (% RAM usage) firefox would decide it's time to free cache. While using the 100% of RAM might be the optimal state if you aren't going to use more than that, it's not safe.
How, exactly?
Or put another way, how do you reliably tell apart "we are seriously thrashing" and "resident memory is getting close to the physical memory limits but there is plenty of totally cold stuff to swap out and it won't be a problem" from userspace? The kernel is the only thing that can make that determination somewhat reliably.