Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Here's a HN story from a while back titled "The Man Behind Windows PowerShell"[0].

Of the 129 comments on that story, not one discussed how software development at Microsoft is always a team effort. Or checked any repositories counting LoC to quantify the value of his contribution.

Meanwhile, in this thread, I see 6 of 73 comments as of now not discussing a woman's relative contribution to a team effort, and how she does or does not deserve praise.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15250349



Not really a fitting comparison. Snover is describing himself as inventor of power shell, he pushed the project against resistance of his peers/superiors in Microsoft and implemented the first prototype. Without him it simply wouldn’t exist.


Without her, this wouldn’t exist.


Top post:

>It's a miserable language, full of unexpected behaviors and badly designed features.

I agree. That no one is tearing apart the horribly written python in the git repo is extremely sexist.

Holy shit, you're using comments as version control, the 70s called and what their code practices back.

Oh my god, did you even read the thread? It gets better with each post:

>I haven't met a single person who likes PowerShell. It's perhaps the textbook example of ugly design that looks technically consistent but utterly unfriendly and mind bogglingly verbose. [...] The designers of this thing should have been demoted, let alone making them "Distinguished Engineer".

>PowerShell is one of the few bits of software which has actually made me throw a computer in anger. The idea has potential but the implementation is just bad.

And they go on and on.


At least they're talking about PowerShell rather than gender!


This is why I'd wish we stopped seeing people's individual achievements in relation to the groups they belong to. I've noticed recently whenever a girl or black guy achieves anything some people (often rightly) become suspicious that their achievements are being exaggerated or are due to quotas or affirmative action. And that robs the individual of the credit they deserve.


Also not one person complained about how the journalist was making Such A Big Deal out of his gender and overblowig his accomplishments by using the word “man”.


If you ask people in the know "who is the person behind Windows PowerShell?" it is very likely that they will agree.

I wouldn't expect the answer to "who is the person behind the first black hole image?" to be so clear.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: