Ah, seeing as you are a mod (I assume) that makes sense so all I can do is apologize for my response. The quick look at your comment history looked to me like all you did was jump on people for having opinions.
I still support the comment pointing out the generalisation of smart people and believe it's also fair to give a frank opinion of such arrogant assumptions without being told your opinion isn't "substantive" enough.
I'm sorry the mod thing wasn't clear. Of course we've thought about adding 'mod' tags to the relevant usernames (dang and sctb), but it somehow feels out of sync with the spirit and traditions of this place.
I still support the comment pointing out the generalisation of smart people and believe it's also fair to give a frank opinion of such arrogant assumptions without being told your opinion isn't "substantive" enough.