Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I have decided it must be attached to a sort of superiority complex. These types of people believe they are capable of deciphering fact from fiction but the general population isn’t so LLMs scare them because someone might hear something wrong and believe it. It almost seems delusional. You have to be incredibly self aggrandizing in your mind to think this way. If LLMs were actually causing “a problem” then there would be countless examples of humans making critical mistakes because of bad LLM responses, and that is decidedly not happening. Instead we’re just having fun ghiblifying the last 20 years of the internet.


> that is decidedly not happening

Regardless of anything else it’s extremely too early to make such claims. We have to wait until people start allowing “AI agents” to make autonomous blackbox decision with minimal supervision since nobody has any clue what’s happening.

Even if we tone down the SciFi dystopia angle not that many people really use LMMs in non superficial ways yet. What I’m most afraid of would be the next generation growing without the ability to critically synthesize information on their own.


Most people - the vast majority of people - cannot critically synthesize information on their own.

But the implication of what you are saying is that academic rigour is going to be ditched overnight because of LLMs.

That’s a little bit odd. Has the scientific community ever thrown up its collective hands and said “ok, there are easier ways to do things now, we can take the rest of the decade off, phew what a relief!”


> what you are saying is that academic rigour is going to be ditched overnight

Not across all level and certainly not overnight. But a lot of children entering the pipeline might end up having a very different experience than anyone else before LLMs (unless they are very lucky to be in an environment that provides them better opportunities).

> cannot critically synthesize information on their own.

That’s true, but if we even less people will try to so that or even know where to start that will get even worse.


No matter how things will evolve, that Ghiblification is something we will look back to in twenty years and say: "Remember how cool that was?"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: